Recently, Press Council of Nepal (PCN) issued a letter seeking clarification from MySansar, Nepal’s most popular blog. This is first time that PCN has recognized the presence of a blog. This incident should also encourage the government – and its agencies – to have a policy about online media.

THE STORY

MySansar.com published a series of blog entries – including one by Om Thapa that was reproduced with permission from a weekly, Janaastha, on Binod Chaudhary. Chaudhary is a noted industrialist leading the Chaudhary Group (CG). The blogs were about alleged tax invading by CG in the light of the action initiated by the Ministry of Finance on tax invasion and fraud by 27 companies. The ministry has not yet named the companies, but the blog claimed CG is one of them.

The blog entries also claimed that CG also ‘forced’ Finance Minister Bharat Mohan Adhikari of actions leading to resignation of finance secretary Rameshwor Khanal. One of the post also criticized mainstream media for publication Chaudhary’s article claiming that the big percentage of the tax that the industrialist claimed to have paid is in fact the taxes collected by people during sales of their products.

CG STRIKES BACK

The first response of CG was writing a lot of comments accusing the blogger of being biased and drunkard. I know Umesh Shrestha, the mysansar blogger, for many years now and I have never seen him drink – even socially, and that led him to check the IPs of the commentators and he found that those comments were coming from the network of CG.

He exposed the IPs leading to criticism by bloggers and tweeples for unethical practice – but that’s another story.

Then CG moved to PCN. Mahesh Pant, the executive assistant to Binod Kumar Chaudhary, wrote to PCN requesting necessary action claiming that mysansar.com ‘attempted character assassination of Chaudhary by flowing wrong, one-sided and misleading information using profanity’. Pant also asked PCN to ensure that such information would not flow in the future.

MYSANSAR’S REPLY

Mysansar.com sent a written clarification to PCN saying that the published blog posts were not wrong/misleading or biased rather they were based on facts made available by confidential sources. It also said that there is no substantial proof or logic in complaint filed by Pant.

PCN is yet to decide on the issue. However, it’s likely that the code of conduct monitoring committee will not close the case.

QUESTIONS ARISEN

Although mysansar.com did a laudable job by replying to the PCN, the ‘blogs’ however are not under PCN jurisdiction according to applicable law. The Press Council Act, and the Code of Conduct that PCN has formulated, is silent on blog. The government and/or PCN doesn’t have a policy regarding blogs.

PCN sent the letter using email and it didn’t name anyone. Even the complainer thought that Om Thapa, whose news from Janaastha, were reproduced is the owner of the site.

In such scenario, there are many questions that immediately needed to be looked upon. The most important question is: is blogger a journalist? Going by the way PCN has taken the case, it proves that the blogger is indeed a journalist and thus should have the rights to protect his sources. In mysansar case, the blogger is also a journalist working for a mainstream media. Do all blogger has that right?

The increasing influence of blogs, note that mysansar.com is ranked ahead of many mainstream news site of Nepal, has forced the companies like CG to take them seriously. But a blog can be run and operated outside Nepal, and even if it’s from within Nepal, the blogger can be anonymous, what can PCN do if there are more complaints?

Normally, the code of conduct action by PCN is related in classification and government advertisements. However, blogs are neither classified nor they receive government advertisements. So even if PCN initiate action on valid case, there is nothing they can actually do.

ACTION NEEDED

It’s against the standard norms to ask blogs for compulsory registration. But there also a need that somehow the PCN needed to monitor blogs and bring them under their jurisdiction.

So the need of the hour is to have a clear policy on online news site and blogs. Blogs could have optional registration process, classification and also a pie of government advertisements. The Code of Conduct should also be updated to include the dynamics of online media.

It’s high time for PCN to initiate steps in that direction and that could well begin with round table discussions with online journalists and bloggers.

39 Thoughts on “Is blog under Press Council jurisdiction?

  1. Anonymous on 5/8/2011 at 12:30 pm said:

    Great and Important Issue!

    And now as you are in the executive committee of the council (congrats for that!), I hope you will take your time to address this and other several issues related to blog.

  2. I’m elected to Federation of Nepali Journalists (FNJ) – not PCN but if opportunity arises, I will surely try my best to push for addressing of bloggers’ issues.

  3. While mainstream media houses are loosing their journalistic value influenced by Corporate houses ( Corrupted Houses ) citizen journalism is only the way. So don care about PCN there is no force to do anything

  4. Blog is all about citizen journalism. And citizen journalism is a booming. So, it would be better, PCN stay away from this.

    I don’t know why, they wish to censor everything.

    As you said, “It’s high time for PCN to initiate steps in that direction and that
    could well begin with round table discussions with online journalists
    and bloggers.” Yes, it is.

    And I condemn the steps taken by PCN against mysansar.com

  5. Binayaguragain on 5/8/2011 at 3:51 pm said:

    This is genuine issue raised. Actually this is a question is blogger journalists? are new media or social media users journalists? Lets see how NPC and FNJ acts to addressing such emerging challenges.

  6. blog is personal property and it is unethical for them trying to censor on blog, beside this mysansar has already stated it is a blog not a news site , even mainstream media now fail to put exact and true news recent example is of anuja

  7. online media should be independent, (preferably) public. Of course online media person (blogger, tweeters or any form online user) should have their responsibility along with power that should be governed by national IT laws. Unless an online user is also a mainstream journalist and specifically uses online media as a complement to the mainstream media, I believe they shouldn’t be treated like journalists or acted upon by mainstream laws.

  8. A blogger is not a journalist who are paid by a corporation. Even a most detested journalist can survive (a living example – Aashis Luitel) – a most detested blogger can never survive. The whole idea of journalism fails at that point.

    It’s good that Umesh replied to PCN’s letter (yes, he is a journalist). I wouldn’t expect anybody else to do the same.

    Online ‘journalism’ doesn’t need ‘uninvited regulators’.

    While positive suggestions and recommendations are welcomed, setting boundaries will be futile.

  9. Pingback: Is Nepal’s Press Council a Toy Now? | Nepal Blogs

  10. Bhumika Ghimire (@bhumikaghimire:twitter ) has a blog post on the issue:

    http://bhumikasa.wordpress.com/2011/05/09/is-nepals-press-council-a-toy-now/

  11. Binayaguragain on 5/9/2011 at 12:45 pm said:

    Ujjwal ji – this is genuine issue. Personally I would say that this does not fall under the jurisdiction of Press Council. agreed with other comments below that blog should be freed of censor and regulation. But the other side is we as a blogger also have social responsibility as content of blog is also appeared in the internet so how it become public interest. To hear how other (traditional media users and NPC) think of this issues I have an idea. As you are also elected member of FNJ, I can imagine you should understand this much better than other member in FNJ that bloggers are journalists or not. Hence, I would propose to have a discussion at large where rep of NPC, FNJ chair and member should join and discuss this issues whether blog is under the jurisdiction or not. Do you mind if we (Equal Access, MeroReport) should initiate idea of having collective discussion sometime early next week where EA should take lead in inviting you, Umesh ji and other bloggers plus we should invite NPC, FNJ people at the same forum. This is emerging issues for Nepal so I realized the need of having constructive debate instead of saying yes or no. We should initiate. I have already spoken to NPC and Shiva dai and found they both are interested to move forward. What do you say?

    Binaya Guragain – Program Coordinator, Equal Access

  12. Binaya ji, it would really be a nice initiative to help PCN/Govt step towards clear policy towards online media. I suggest that online news website journalists should also be included so that discussion will cover emerging online media. I, as a blogger and FNJ member, will always be there for any initiation on online media.

  13. Pingback: ?? ???? ??????? ?? ? ????? ????????, ????????, ? ????? ????? | ?????? ??

  14. Binayaguragain on 5/12/2011 at 3:53 pm said:

    Ujjwal ji, this debate has been proposed to be held on coming Monday. I will send you with invitation tomorrow. and definitely, I will include online journalists in the participants lists. Thanks for your flexibility. PCN and FNJ member also expected to join this discussion.

  15. Sale on 5/13/2011 at 2:51 am said:

    ALSO NOTE: The crimes committed by right-wing dictators have always been easier to track down than the crimes against humanity committed by communist leaders, so the figures for communist leaders like Stalin and Mao increase almost yearly as new secret documents become available. To this day, the Chinese government has not yet disclosed how many people were executed by Mao’s red guards during the Cultural Revolution and how many people were killed in Tibet during the Chinese invasion of 1950. We also don’t know how many dissidents have been killed by order of Kim Il Sung in North Korea, although presumably many thousands.

  16. Sale on 5/13/2011 at 3:00 am said:

     I do not want to take direction away from your post – sorry for that but it had to be mentioned at this point in time. 

    As for the Chadharys – I also heard that the budget was actually being made in the Chaudhary niwas NOT the Finance Ministry. 

    It is time to lock these chaps away as well – we are beginning to lock up corrupt politicians and MP’s and now it is time to lock away corrupt industrialist who are part of the problem for this nation. 

    Chaudhary group has been trying to sugar coat their image these days – we know they have stumbled upon good fortune after the palace massacre and had direct access to the illegal wealth of the late Queen and King- but with no one living from the immediate family with the knowledge to claim it, the Chaudhary’s who were just the bag men and arm’s dealers to the royalty all through the Panchayat and later have ceased the opportunity and ceased the funds as well – why do you think they have grown from being one of the largest defaulters until 2005 to becoming a “billion dollar company” worldwide literally overnight. People do not build billion dollar (In rupees 75 arabs) empires in a couple of years from being a major defaulter. So now the Chaudhary’s are running the biggest cover up in Nepal’s business history by sugar coating these funds which belong to the nation – as all of the former royal’s property had been trusted so too should all these international funds – but the greedy Chaudhary’s keep paying people off and running a great scam. 

  17. This particular seems more like typically the RIAA exploit the lawful technique for a quick profit when compared with them actually wishing to prevent pirating. Really such as songs is just often the bait for genuine profit-making machine. I actually would not always be shocked once they leaked their unique songs about the net. While this individual genuinely should not possess downloadable the background music, the one thing the actual jury have to find here’s how influenced typically the “victim” is actually as well as assign punishment as necessary. If it’s 7 sounds, drop all of them $7 us dollars. That might be rights. Not necessarily this excessive quantity.

  18. Joel In my opinion you must state a good in order to new music just as the to health care and after that we could most demand the grimy rich music artists and bands as well as file businesses have to offer that to help all of us. In my opinion that the open public alternative might also be desired. all the best ! Sue Detect the way the concept “fine” is actually cast in relation to? Pay out for just a reduction seems to be viewed as a great and a excellent accessed by simply personal organization. One issue of countless completely wrong with this particular. The particular prize levied in opposition to you has been progressive associated with series. Shoplifting might usually possibly be $125. 00 issue could well be seen as any “fine. inches This company this received myself made a false complaint proclaiming I viewed right now there tv development when i must have been a compensated advertiser. That they referred to as the idea a superb also. Even though presently there the courtroom complaint must have been a dupery but not real, not a soul actually cared and I failed to can afford to purchase litigation for just a demo. In reality falsified documented data was downloaded with out a single blinked an eye. Situations everywhere scam is authorized or settlement will be solution regarding brand will probably catch up with all of our rights method because every time the idea happen, that technique looses believability since you can easily read inside the posts preceding this one. If fake the courtroom grievances are generally permitted as well as awards are extremely outside of range it truly is confident the program is not considerable and also fair.

  19. itssss wonderful sorts……… least difficult…….!!!! thanks a lot a great deal for spreading & conserving everyones period…….. thanks I must find out about 80g this season. If we could estimate 80G within froth not any 10 or not I would want to consider some sort of Metro-only product by Xbox 360 the usage, I love typically the to pick from screen, nevertheless I have zero affinity for Windows like a personal computer OS nowadays. A lot of infections, adware, dives, lots of issues. Typically the Macintosh personal computer is often a superior pc OPERATING-SYSTEM without any dives and complications, though the ipad tablet to me seems like a new gadget nonetheless and it is impossible to get critical work done onto it in addition to reading and writing some small emails. We think this is a limit in order to drugs, but Microsoft is surely an business office efficiency corporation so if any person can display any fruitful capsule it really is these.

  20. where to buy a birkin bag ywclbmtwmjh hermes togo bags zapcbhhrtsz

  21. A fantastic songs website, in my view, is certainly one which includes EVERY THING, including the tunes. We have examined every web site, the sole a couple which are worthy of the time are usually 8tracks and Grooveshark.

  22. spotify is the best i’ve at any time applied as well as i’ve utilized nearly all. issue is it’s not designed for typically the Ough. H. if you have any friends dwelling beyond your U. S i9000., make them call and make an account and give the information. is often a inconvenience, yet worthwhile.

  23. I recognize a few of these however I will check the remaining all of them out. The principle spot I actually hear tunes are at blip. fm. I really like the idea!

  24. One of my very own conference speeches is named Structured Homeschool. I love to listen to brand new issues individuals accomplish.

  25. As a result of ()z by Drive 22nd. Of course functioned a treat along with ended up saving us a lot of reading through as well as searching. I really didn’t recognize their very own uploads/downloads would be p2p. My spouse and i operate peerguardian as well as a couple ip’s retained turning up (blocked admittedly). These people were BSky F about 193. 195. 117. 136 along with Displaying Press about 193. 114. 117. 134. These kinds of are equally long gone currently and so very happy thank you. I possess no trouble with Stones about this issue truly although a few the people definitely more than likely can locate a new deal ore also learn there were an issue. Anyway, information aid There are only uncovered Kservice skulking on my unit immediately after trying to exchange Sky Simply by Broadband internet from a unit to another. Simply to confess I put special occasion to be able to wedding ring Heavens technical assistance repeatedly during the process (and haven’t succeeded to do the idea yet). They are really good individuals but are relatively hopeless. A possibility which they no longer let you know about Kontiki which is described over the internet to enroll in the actual service -it’s which they can’t say for sure precisely how functions or even how much difficulty it can be to help uninistall that. I had been advised getting rid SkY By simply BB seemed to be as fundamental as add/remove plans. It’s, simply because Kontiki continues to be operating out. The technological help support aren’t becoming deceitful, IMHO these people just simply how to start much. My partner and i suspect often the probs I use experienced transporting SBB from a DESKTOP to a new happen to be caused by typically the Kontiki app nonetheless managing on my multilevel. Ever since I see how much difficulty Kontiki is to take out On the web not sure if I need to maneuver SBB whatsoever I will simply drop this.

  26. birkin bag replica best aaa sioxre hermes cuffs australia fcngqlt

  27. Arizona city most wealthy You.Second. area

  28. Greetings from Florida! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch break. I love the knowledge you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how quick your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, fantastic site!

  29. Journal asiatique ReporterWeekly a ?t? fond?e en 1991 en mettant l’accent sur les nouvelles et les ?v?nements d’Asie.

  30. Alors que Mgr Hubbard s’approcha de son d?part ? la retraite obligatoire ? 75 ans, la perspective d’un successeur soulev? inqui?tude, en particulier ? la lumi?re de la papaut? d’un leader conservateur ? Rome, Beno?t XVI. Le nouvel ?v?que serait partager le m?me engagement pour la justice sociale et de la coll?gialit? que la communaut? est venu ? ch?rir ? Bishop Hubbard?

  31. hermes birkin philippines tumblr tilfpclo hermes hotel dubai youtube qugftmc

  32. I really enjoy these kind of The best wow gold sales on Australia. i’m certainly watchful by way of our bait therefore soon after A few months they are really continue to appearing like this closed fist time of day i applied individuals, does one accept it. i will express if you take care of them and they are carefull the place you are them you’ll have these folks for some time. i have never viewed a particular dilemma however. Make certain one through attention system.

  33. Otha Anderson, 56 passa trouve ? 13 F?vrier 2011 ? partir de sa r?sidence. Otha a travaill? ? DeSoto de bois franc comme un op?rateur de machine. Lewis Sons Funeral Home a la charge. Il laisse ? ch?rir sa m?moire aimer un fils Otha Anderson, Jr. Lewis Sons Funeral Home, 374 Vance Ave. ? vrai Baptist Church Lumi?re, 4635 Stage Rd. avec inhumation au cimeti?re de Galil?e Memorial Gardens.

  34. Si votre magn?tiseur est un morceau d’acier ou de fer, appuyez sur l’aiguille ? magn?tiser. Si vous utilisez une aiguille ? coudre, ins?rer horizontalement dans la tranche de la pi?ce de taille morceau de li?ge, de sorte que les aiguille perce ? travers le bouchon et sort de l’autre c?t?. Pousser l’aiguille ? travers jusqu’? ce que la m?me quantit? de l’aiguille fait saillie de part et d’autre du bouchon.

  35. Each program or even computer software provides their pros in addition to crons so its absolutely drastically wrong sighting the actual awful favorable the item. It offers almost all of the excellent factors so when some time passes all these weak points will probably be soughted away. . -= GadgetGuide4U’s last blog site… Digg Software For Android is already Avaiable =-.

  36. I just want to mention I’m very new to blogging and site-building and absolutely enjoyed you’re web site. More than likely I’m likely to bookmark your website . You certainly have outstanding articles. With thanks for sharing with us your blog.

  37. You happen to be wright however in the event you invest even more $$, then you can definitely converters gadgets to work with universal series bus products having apple ipad although too costly guy . -= Sunil Jain’s last site… [How to] Customise Retweet Attribute with Multiauthor Wp weblogs =-.

  38. Good story to evaluate imperceptable men and women. But I am likewise looking the item intended for Skype hello there, currently bing provides patched new discover approach furthermore we must wait around some more days with regard to im or her invisible to work flawlessly: )

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title="" rel=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Post Navigation